If you've never been in a room with over 300 Searchers I recommend it. It's the opposite of Private Equity entitlement. These guys are the real deal. They are battle tested and more focused than ever. I love the ETA community and am not sure I've ever met someone in those circles that didn't absolutely impress me. My ETA story goes like this… Covid tanked the IT recruiting space so I started a Concrete Coatings Business. 3-4 years later I listed the business through a broker and sold it in 6 months. After a quick trip to Italy and regaining my inner peace, I decided I really enjoyed the M&A world and wanted to help folks buy and sell businesses. There's no rush like sitting on the couch at 11pm, scrolling BizBuySell, when you find THE ONE.
"Established 12 years. $520,000 SDE. Owner absentee. Motivated seller." Your heart rate jumps; you’re in love. Before you know it, you’ve fired off an inquiry, signed an NDA, and spend the next three weeks determining just how in love you really are.
I spent years working with clients on the buy side and I can tell you that the search is hard and getting that first nibble on the line is intoxicating. Understanding the deal from being on the seller side helped me put together a playbook where we always keep the seller in mind. Here it is.
1. Read the listing like a skeptic, not a fan
Listings are marketing, and the broker's job is to get your attention. That's fine, but read it the way you'd read a used car ad and don't hold it against the broker. Small Business Brokers are often just used car/business sales guys.
Watch for:
- "SDE" or "cash flow" with no revenue listed. If they won't show revenue, ask yourself why.
- "Owner absentee" or "semi-absentee." Sometimes it's true. Often it means the owner is there 50 hours a week and thinks they could leave.
- Seller Financing Available. RED FLAG – when this is communicated up front in the CIM or the online posting this almost always means that the deal has been run by a bank and cannot be financed at the Asking Price. If the bank won't finance, neither should you (through a Seller's Note). Seller Financing is a great strategy for Buyers but it's not a good sign when the Seller leads with it.
- Round numbers. $500,000 cash flow on $1,000,000 revenue is a 50% margin. Possible, but rare for most Main Street businesses.
- "Add-backs available upon request." Translation: the profit number depends on things you haven't seen yet.
2. Do the 60-second math
Before you do anything else, run three numbers on a napkin:
- Asking price ÷ claimed SDE. Most small businesses trade somewhere around 2 to 4 times SDE. If it's 6x, there's either a great story or a big problem.
- SDE ÷ revenue. That's the margin. Compare it to what's normal for the industry. A landscaping company claiming 45% margins deserves a hard look.
- Can the business pay you and the loan? If you're using an SBA loan, the debt payment comes out of that SDE before you get paid. A $520K SDE can turn into a $90K salary very fast.
If a deal fails the napkin test, you just saved yourself three weeks.
3. Understand the add-backs before anyone sells you on them
This is where most buyers get burned, and where I'd spend your attention.
An add-back is an expense the seller says won't continue once you own it, so it gets added back to profit. Some are completely fair: the owner's salary, a one-time lawsuit, a personal car run through the business.
Others are wishful thinking:
- "My wife's on payroll but doesn't really work here." (Who's doing that work after you buy it?)
- "That was a one-time equipment repair." (It's the third year in a row.)
- "We pay a lot of cash under the table, so real profit is higher." (Walk away. You can't finance, verify, or legally take over unreported cash.)
The rule: every add-back should be something you can trace in the tax returns or the books. If it only exists in the broker's spreadsheet, it doesn't exist.
4. Ask for the right documents up front
When you do reach out, don't just ask for "more info." Ask for:
- 3 years of business tax returns
- 3 years of P&Ls, plus year to date
- Recent balance sheets
- The add-back schedule
A lot of brokers will send a CIM (confidential information memorandum) first. That's fine, but a CIM is still marketing. Tax returns are what the seller told the IRS, and that's usually the most honest number in the whole package.
If the numbers in the CIM and the tax returns don't match, the gap is the story. This can be a solvable problem but stay critically minded. Ask to speak with the CPA or bookkeeper to understand any discrepancies.
5. Screen it before you fall in love with it
This is why I built LiteQoE.
A full Quality of Earnings report from a CPA firm runs $10,000 or more and takes weeks. That's the right tool after you've signed an LOI and you're serious. But nobody can spend $10,000+ on every listing that catches their eye. So, most buyers either skip the analysis early on or try to do it themselves in a spreadsheet at midnight. (See how a Lite QoE compares to a full QoE.)
With LiteQoE, you upload what the broker sent you (tax returns, P&Ls, balance sheets, bank statements) and get a screen back in 1 to 2 hours for $199. You're only doing this if your "napkin math" looks solid. The LiteQoE Screen normalizes the earnings, checks the add-backs against the tax returns and books, grades the health of the business, and tells you what to dig into next. Or whether to walk.
Our sample report shows what that looks like: a listing claiming $520,000 in earnings where the supported number was $467,000. On a 3x multiple, that $53,000 gap is about $159,000 of purchase price. You can also browse all our samples.
It isn't a CPA-attested report and it doesn't replace a full QoE. It's the step before that, the one that helps you decide whether a deal deserves an LOI and how to structure that LOI. When you're ready, you can hand it to your CPA with the included CPA handoff package.
6. Then call the broker, with better questions
Once you've screened a deal, your first broker call changes completely. Instead of "tell me about the business," you're asking:
- "The 2024 return shows $410K in net income, but the add-back schedule gets to $520K. Can you walk me through the $110K?"
- "Revenue dipped 8% last year. What happened?"
- "Which of these add-backs will the lender accept?"
Brokers take buyers who ask questions like that seriously. You'll get faster answers and better access, and you'll negotiate from facts instead of feelings.
The bottom line
Every listing on BizBuySell is someone's life's work, and some of them are great businesses. Your job is to find out which ones, quickly and cheaply, before your heart decides for you.
